top of page

Milburn review summary and what it means for providers and lifelong learning

Writer: LEI
LEI
1 hour ago
6 min read
Alan Milburn’s new deal for young people puts first jobs back on the agenda

The much-anticipated Milburn Review starts from the diagnosis of a deep-seated structural and systemic failure rather than a temporary economic cycle.


The key arguments point to:


  • Shrinking entry-level pathways. The labour market no longer absorbs young workers at the rate it once did. Entry-level roles have fallen by 49% in the last decade, while apprenticeships for young people (18-24) have fallen by 40%.


  • Decades of systemic dysfunction. Milburn attributed the trend to long-term failures across schools, health services, welfare, and employment support. He noted that an unfit school curriculum, fragmented public services, and high hiring costs for employers have created a "perfect storm".


  • Youth detachment rather than unemployment. A growing share of young people are not just temporarily between jobs. 57% of UK NEETs are economically inactive, 61.6% have never held a job, and 44% report work-limiting health conditions.


  • Early childhood roots. The review emphasised that disengagement often starts long before adulthood. Persistent childhood poverty, school absences, and a lack of family connections to secure first jobs leave disadvantaged young people locked out of the workforce.


  • Demographic and geographic patterns. NEETs are more likely to be from lower social backgrounds, more likely to be male, and most concentrated in the North and Midlands.


  • Shifting skills profile. There is a significant shift in the educational background of NEETs. 15% hold a university degree or equivalent, while over 21% hold a Level 3 qualification, and nearly 30% have achieved good GCSE grades. In total, roughly 35% are qualified to A-level standard or above.


The review proposes a "whole system reset" across welfare, health, education, and employment to cut the UK NEET rate from around 13% to about 5% by 2036. Key changes include:


  • New Youth Benefits System: This would replace current support for under-25s with a youth allowance, ending automatic access to the Universal Credit health top-up and Personal Independence Payment (PIP) for this age group.


  • Devolved Youth Opportunity Service: A local service across every area by 2029, run by mayors and strategic authorities, combining employment, career, and health support. Young people would meet a named adviser within 14 days, get a participation plan within four weeks, be guaranteed a route into work, training, or education after four months, and qualify for a grant if still NEET after six months.


  • Health and Sickness Reforms: Shift from treating illness after it escalates to early intervention and faster mental health support. This moves long-term youth sickness absence management away from GP surgeries toward specialist health and pro-active employment support, treating ‘fit notes’ as the start of active support.


  • Employer Incentives: The review suggests financial incentives and potential tax cuts for businesses that hire young people, this could include a reduction in employer NICs for 21- to 24-year-olds, beginning in hospitality and retail. In addition the review suggests direct grants of £3,000 to £7,000 for businesses hiring young people who have been NEET for six months.


What it means for providers


The review has wide reaching implications for all providers of education and skills. Schools, colleges, and universities will not just be judged on qualifications, but on how well young people transition into further learning or work, aiming first to eliminate NEETs among 16- and 17-year-olds. Additionally, all institutions will have to surrender some autonomy. Strategic authorities and mayors will hold multi-year "Participation Agreements," meaning providers must align their course offers directly with regional labour market needs. While all schools, colleges, and training providers will be legally and operationally tied into the new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) by 2029, sharing data and coordinating individual "Participation Plans" with health and employment advisers.


Further Education (FE) Colleges. Milburn proposes making FE colleges England’s "principal technical and transition institution," backed by major capacity expansion alongside stricter accountability.


  • Capacity Expansion. The review calls for automatic increases to the 16–19 budget in line with student numbers to absorb an extra 150,000 18-to-24-year-olds annually across FE and training providers. Government has already guaranteed a funded college place for every young person that wants one.


  • Outcome-Linked Funding. College funding would shift away from pure headcount toward how students perform and whether they progress into jobs or further study.


  • Work-Readiness Inspections. Ofsted, the Department for Education, and regional mayors would judge colleges against new published work-readiness and destination metrics.


  • In-Year Funding Flexibility. Colleges would receive more responsive funding when young people drop back into education mid-year, plus a new funding premium for supporting students at high risk of becoming NEET.


Independent Training & Apprenticeship Providers. The review makes apprenticeships and technical training the "first priority" for public investment, aiming to double youth apprenticeship achievements over ten years so they rival university as a mainstream route.


  • Scrapping English and Maths Barriers. Training providers would no longer be blocked from completing young apprentices who have not passed Level 2 English and maths exams.


  • New Pre-Apprenticeship Programmes. Providers will be commissioned to run new pre-apprenticeship pathways to bridge the gap for disengaged young people.


  • Focus on Under-25s. The review urges the Treasury to stop withholding apprenticeship levy funds, increase incentives for providers and employers training young people, and require employers to contribute more toward training older workers.


Primary & Secondary Schools. Milburn argues that disengagement starts early, requiring schools to identify and intervene with at-risk students long before they leave education.


  • Mandatory Risk Tracking. Both primary and secondary schools would be required to use Risk of NEET Indicator (RONI) tools to track attendance, attainment, and suspension data.


  • Curriculum & Accountability Shifts. Schools would face new accountability measures for "work readiness" alongside a curriculum rebalanced toward employability skills.


  • Curbing Exclusions. Schools would face tighter expectations to reduce permanent exclusions and must create formal transition and participation plans—escalated to local councils and the Youth Opportunity Service—for repeatedly suspended pupils.


Higher Education (Universities). Universities face both new competition from vocational routes and potential funding reprioritisation to pay for FE expansion.


  • Student Finance Cuts. To help fund an initial £500 million investment in youth employment and FE, Milburn identifies cuts to student finance for franchised higher education and foundation-year courses as a key source of savings.


  • Degree apprenticeships. Milburn has resisted the call to move degree apprenticeships onto the standard undergraduate tuition fee and loan model. However, the refocus would cut levy funding for over-25s by 25% (forcing employers to co-invest a quarter of the cost), with the government prepared to cut its contribution by 50% by 2031–32 to divert cash toward young people.


  • Digital Open College. Universities and colleges would be invited to contribute courses to a new "digital open college," part-funded by employers and private investors, to widen flexible access for young people.


What it means for Lifelong Education


Milburn’s structural and financial recommendations have major consequences for lifelong learning and adult education across England. The review observes that the tertiary skills system is fragmented but it has little to say about creating a holistic through life approach to learning.


Milburn explicitly rejects the idea that subsidising employers to upskill existing older staff naturally creates entry-level roles for young people, stating that the "trickle-down" theory of workforce development has failed in practice. The review proposes dismantling that model in favour of demand-side intervention, tilting the system towards direct labour market attachment.


While the review redirects public skills funding away from older adults to pay for young people it does recommend a new infrastructure for modular and lifelong study. It proposes building a flexible, credit-based ecosystem designed to let learners step in and out of education throughout their lives rather than relying on a single full-time course:


  • A National Digital "Open College". Milburn calls for an "Open University for skills" a national digital platform to help learners navigate courses and accumulate credits across colleges, universities, and independent providers. Employers and private investors would co-fund these courses alongside the state.


  • Integration with the Lifelong Learning Entitlement (LLE). The review positions the government's Lifelong Learning Entitlement as an "important building block" for this new Open College.


  • Credit Recognition for Dropouts. Milburn recommends awarding Higher Education diplomas or formal credits to students who leave university early so their completed modules remain portable for future return to study.


Milburn signals that his approach is intended as a blueprint for the wider adult system, noting that design features of the proposed youth system could be extended to the over-25 welfare cohort. While the review does not explicitly suggest a policy shift away towards an integrated co-investment model it is clear that proposals will share costs between individuals (via LLE loans), employers (via higher levy co-payments).

 
 
bottom of page